who・which・that の使い分け
関係代名詞の who・which・that と、関係詞を書かない形が、実際の英文でどう使い分けられているか。先行詞が人か物か、主格か目的格か、名詞に何が付くか、話し言葉か書き言葉かで比べた。
要点
- 物が先行詞なら that が基本主格で that 87%・which 13%。目的格で関係詞を書くなら that 94%。the book that changed my life
- 人が先行詞なら who が基本主格で who 84%・that 15%。whom は目的格でも 7% にとどまる。the man who lives next door
- 目的格は関係詞を書かないのがふつう節の主語が I / you / he などのとき、関係詞なしが 物 69%・人 72%。the book I read / the man I met
- 人の名詞によって that の割合が変わるthe man で that 8%、the girl 19%、the lady 24%、the child 33%、the baby では 54% と who を上回る。the baby that was born last week
- a なら who、that / this なら that が増える人の主格で that は a 11%・the 15%・this 18%・that 25%。that が2つ続くのを避ける形にはなっていない。that guy that was just here
- 書き言葉の物には which が残る物の主格の that は 映画・ドラマ字幕 89% に対して Wikipedia 77%・論文抄録 66%。a method which reduces the error
- カンマの後は which と whoカンマの後の that は 物で 9%・人で 6%。my car, which I bought last year,
- 前置詞の後は which と whomto whom・with whom など人の前置詞の後は whom(9,933件)。物は in which・of which(246,496件)。the person to whom I spoke
先行詞の種類で決まる大筋
主格(関係詞のすぐ後に動詞が来る形)で比べる。物は that、人は who が多数派。集団と動物はその中間で、集団は who が 20%、動物も who が 15%。
先行詞の種類・主格
the book that changed … / the man who lives …
thatwho / whomwhich
数字の表
| 先行詞 | that | % | who / whom | % | which | % | 計 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 物 the book that / which … | 2,233,412 | 87.1% | 0 | 0.0% | 329,897 | 12.9% | 2,563,309 |
| 人 the man who / that … | 228,086 | 15.2% | 1,262,360 | 84.2% | 8,744 | 0.6% | 1,499,190 |
| 集団 the company that / who / which … | 224,093 | 71.0% | 63,039 | 20.0% | 28,372 | 9.0% | 315,504 |
| 動物 the dog that / which / who … | 32,508 | 73.5% | 6,639 | 15.0% | 5,109 | 11.5% | 44,256 |
人が先行詞のとき
同じ人の名詞でも、that の割合は名詞によって違う。the man・the woman は who が9割を超え、子どもに近い語ほど that が増える。
名詞ごと(the + 単数・主格)
the man who … / the man that …
thatwho / whomwhich
数字の表
| 先行詞 | that | % | who / whom | % | which | % | 計 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| the man | 3,684 | 7.7% | 44,227 | 92.3% | 22 | 0.0% | 47,933 |
| the woman | 1,155 | 7.7% | 13,740 | 92.2% | 13 | 0.1% | 14,908 |
| the student | 94 | 12.2% | 673 | 87.3% | 4 | 0.5% | 771 |
| the boy | 499 | 13.0% | 3,335 | 86.9% | 5 | 0.1% | 3,839 |
| the doctor | 267 | 13.6% | 1,689 | 85.7% | 14 | 0.7% | 1,970 |
| the person | 3,853 | 15.0% | 21,833 | 84.9% | 20 | 0.1% | 25,706 |
| the girl | 1,642 | 18.7% | 7,137 | 81.2% | 14 | 0.2% | 8,793 |
| the teacher | 134 | 20.4% | 514 | 78.2% | 9 | 1.4% | 657 |
| the friend | 172 | 21.7% | 621 | 78.2% | 1 | 0.1% | 794 |
| the kid | 539 | 21.7% | 1,938 | 78.0% | 8 | 0.3% | 2,485 |
| the guy | 6,231 | 22.1% | 21,900 | 77.8% | 11 | 0.0% | 28,142 |
| the gentleman | 213 | 22.6% | 728 | 77.4% | 0 | 0.0% | 941 |
| the lady | 543 | 23.6% | 1,757 | 76.2% | 5 | 0.2% | 2,305 |
| the child | 386 | 33.2% | 752 | 64.7% | 24 | 2.1% | 1,162 |
| the baby | 220 | 54.1% | 170 | 41.8% | 17 | 4.2% | 407 |
名詞に付く語でも動く。a が付くといちばん who に寄り、this・that が付くと that が増える。単数より複数のほうが that に寄る。
名詞に付く語ごと(人・主格)
a man who … / that man that …
thatwho / whomwhich
数字の表
| 先行詞 | that | % | who / whom | % | which | % | 計 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a man / a girl | 34,615 | 10.7% | 287,952 | 88.9% | 1,334 | 0.4% | 323,901 |
| my / his … friend | 2,550 | 12.3% | 17,743 | 85.5% | 470 | 2.3% | 20,763 |
| the man / the girl | 28,537 | 14.8% | 162,876 | 84.7% | 826 | 0.4% | 192,239 |
| this man / this girl | 2,646 | 18.0% | 12,029 | 81.7% | 57 | 0.4% | 14,732 |
| that man / that girl | 2,168 | 24.6% | 6,598 | 75.0% | 33 | 0.4% | 8,799 |
| men / people | 92,499 | 15.7% | 491,264 | 83.6% | 3,924 | 0.7% | 587,687 |
| the men / the people | 36,411 | 21.5% | 132,310 | 78.1% | 672 | 0.4% | 169,393 |
| these men | 2,840 | 26.3% | 7,907 | 73.3% | 46 | 0.4% | 10,793 |
| those men | 4,610 | 20.7% | 17,606 | 79.1% | 48 | 0.2% | 22,264 |
話し言葉と書き言葉(人・主格の that の割合)
話し言葉=映画・ドラマ字幕、会話、インタビュー / 書き言葉=ニュース、小説、Wikipedia
| 名詞に付く語 | 話し言葉 | 書き言葉 |
|---|---|---|
| a man / a girl | 12.1% | 5.8% |
| my / his … friend | 14.1% | 12.5% |
| the man / the girl | 16.6% | 9.3% |
| this man / this girl | 17.9% | 15.9% |
| that man / that girl | 25.6% | 18.8% |
| men / people | 17.8% | 11.1% |
| the men / the people | 24.1% | 15.1% |
| these men | 26.8% | 20.2% |
| those men | 23.4% | 14.1% |
話し言葉ではどの形でも that が増えるが、a < the < this < that の順は書き言葉の中でも変わらない(書き言葉で a 6%・the 9%・that 19%)。
人に the only・all などが付くとき
the only・all・every などが付くと that は 15% から 20〜31% に増えるが、どれも who が多数のまま。everyone・anyone・someone は who が 86〜93%。
人が先行詞・主格
all the people who … / the only person who …
thatwho / whomwhich
数字の表
| 先行詞 | that | % | who / whom | % | which | % | 計 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a / the + 名詞 | 228,086 | 15.2% | 1,262,360 | 84.2% | 8,744 | 0.6% | 1,499,190 |
| the only + 名詞 | 3,893 | 20.3% | 15,216 | 79.5% | 42 | 0.2% | 19,151 |
| the same + 名詞 | 1,880 | 24.0% | 5,935 | 75.8% | 14 | 0.2% | 7,829 |
| the + 最上級 + 名詞 | 2,154 | 20.6% | 8,222 | 78.7% | 75 | 0.7% | 10,451 |
| the very + 名詞 | 150 | 13.2% | 987 | 86.8% | 0 | 0.0% | 1,137 |
| the first / last / next + 名詞 | 2,237 | 22.5% | 7,611 | 76.6% | 92 | 0.9% | 9,940 |
| all (the) + 名詞 | 5,099 | 24.8% | 15,424 | 74.9% | 74 | 0.4% | 20,597 |
| every + 名詞 | 2,159 | 30.5% | 4,900 | 69.3% | 13 | 0.2% | 7,072 |
| any + 名詞 | 2,961 | 23.6% | 9,551 | 76.1% | 41 | 0.3% | 12,553 |
| no + 名詞 | 618 | 25.5% | 1,789 | 73.7% | 21 | 0.9% | 2,428 |
| each + 名詞 | 316 | 30.3% | 706 | 67.7% | 21 | 2.0% | 1,043 |
| everyone | 2,657 | 14.2% | 16,042 | 85.7% | 22 | 0.1% | 18,721 |
| anyone | 4,987 | 9.4% | 47,969 | 90.6% | 16 | 0.0% | 52,972 |
| someone | 7,961 | 7.2% | 101,831 | 92.7% | 31 | 0.0% | 109,823 |
| nobody | 403 | 27.8% | 1,045 | 72.1% | 1 | 0.1% | 1,449 |
物が先行詞のとき
物では名詞に付く語で which はあまり動かない。that book の後でも which は増えない。my・its などが付いたときだけ which が多い(23%)。
名詞に付く語ごと(物・主格)
the book that … / that book which …
thatwhich
数字の表
| 先行詞 | that | % | which | % | 計 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a book | 568,926 | 88.1% | 76,983 | 11.9% | 645,909 |
| the book | 333,906 | 87.6% | 47,456 | 12.4% | 381,362 |
| this book | 26,292 | 85.6% | 4,436 | 14.4% | 30,728 |
| that book | 13,544 | 88.1% | 1,821 | 11.9% | 15,365 |
| my / its … book | 30,636 | 77.1% | 9,091 | 22.9% | 39,727 |
| books | 634,367 | 87.2% | 92,896 | 12.8% | 727,263 |
| the books | 188,688 | 91.2% | 18,315 | 8.8% | 207,003 |
| these books | 11,262 | 88.4% | 1,485 | 11.6% | 12,747 |
| those books | 13,916 | 87.5% | 1,985 | 12.5% | 15,901 |
the only・all・every などが付くと which が減り、everything・anything・nothing ではほぼ that だけになる。the first / last / next と each だけは which が増える。
物が先行詞・主格
the only thing that matters / everything that happened
thatwhich
数字の表
| 先行詞 | that | % | which | % | 計 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a / the + 名詞 | 2,233,412 | 87.1% | 329,897 | 12.9% | 2,563,309 |
| the only + 名詞 | 29,603 | 95.1% | 1,534 | 4.9% | 31,137 |
| the same + 名詞 | 10,212 | 92.1% | 876 | 7.9% | 11,088 |
| the + 最上級 + 名詞 | 16,921 | 91.5% | 1,577 | 8.5% | 18,498 |
| the very + 名詞 | 1,557 | 91.4% | 147 | 8.6% | 1,704 |
| the first / last / next + 名詞 | 18,798 | 84.2% | 3,536 | 15.8% | 22,334 |
| all (the) + 名詞 | 33,288 | 93.5% | 2,296 | 6.5% | 35,584 |
| every + 名詞 | 7,775 | 96.0% | 328 | 4.0% | 8,103 |
| any + 名詞 | 28,769 | 92.2% | 2,428 | 7.8% | 31,197 |
| no + 名詞 | 8,976 | 91.5% | 829 | 8.5% | 9,805 |
| each + 名詞 | 2,112 | 85.4% | 361 | 14.6% | 2,473 |
| everything | 26,674 | 99.0% | 257 | 1.0% | 26,931 |
| anything | 32,092 | 98.2% | 601 | 1.8% | 32,693 |
| nothing | 7,678 | 97.6% | 187 | 2.4% | 7,865 |
| something | 102,735 | 96.6% | 3,653 | 3.4% | 106,388 |
目的格では関係詞を書かないのがふつう
節の主語が I / you / he などの目的格で比べる。どの先行詞でも関係詞なしが7割前後。書くなら物は that、人も that が多く(72%)、who は 20%・whom は 7%。
目的格(節の主語が代名詞)
the book ___ I read / the man ___ I met
thatwho / whomwhich関係詞なし
数字の表
| 先行詞 | that | % | who / whom | % | which | % | 関係詞なし | % | 計 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 物 the book ___ I read | 334,262 | 29.1% | 2,126 | 0.2% | 21,628 | 1.9% | 788,979 | 68.8% | 1,146,995 |
| 人 the man ___ I met | 44,871 | 19.9% | 16,707 | 7.4% | 864 | 0.4% | 162,575 | 72.3% | 225,017 |
| 集団 the company ___ we chose | 18,642 | 26.5% | 895 | 1.3% | 1,327 | 1.9% | 49,470 | 70.3% | 70,334 |
| 動物 the dog ___ we keep | 2,279 | 23.2% | 83 | 0.8% | 217 | 2.2% | 7,244 | 73.7% | 9,823 |
| everything ___ I know | 11,559 | 16.2% | 2 | 0.0% | 34 | 0.0% | 59,784 | 83.8% | 71,379 |
| the only person ___ I trust | 614 | 12.8% | 162 | 3.4% | 0 | 0.0% | 4,022 | 83.8% | 4,798 |
| the man ___ he used to be | 2,190 | 15.7% | 217 | 1.6% | 14 | 0.1% | 11,498 | 82.6% | 13,919 |
人の目的格で関係詞を書くとき、a や my が付くと who・whom が増える(a 37%・my など 39%・the 17%)。
人の目的格で関係詞を書くとき
a man whom I met / the man that I met
thatwho / whomwhich
数字の表
| 先行詞 | that | % | who / whom | % | which | % | 計 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a man ___ I met | 6,631 | 61.1% | 4,055 | 37.4% | 160 | 1.5% | 10,846 |
| my friend ___ I met | 2,469 | 57.3% | 1,693 | 39.3% | 148 | 3.4% | 4,310 |
| the man ___ I met | 19,078 | 82.3% | 3,942 | 17.0% | 161 | 0.7% | 23,181 |
| this man ___ I met | 1,525 | 66.5% | 758 | 33.1% | 10 | 0.4% | 2,293 |
| that man ___ I met | 563 | 76.3% | 167 | 22.6% | 8 | 1.1% | 738 |
書き手による違い
only・all などが付かない名詞の主格で、that を使った割合(物は which との比、人は who との比)。
物が先行詞:that の割合
論文・Wikipedia には which が残る
人が先行詞:that の割合
話し言葉ほど that が増える
カンマの後・前置詞の後・whose
- カンマの後は which と who物が先行詞でカンマの後は which が 91%、人は who が中心で that は 6%。
- 前置詞の後は whom と which人は to whom・with whom(9,933件)、物は in which・of which(246,496件)。
- whose は物にも使うwhose の先行詞は 人 38,488 / 物 25,673 / 集団 6,103。
参考書の「that が好まれる場合」は当たるか
- (1)the only / the same / 最上級 などが付く 物なら当たる・人は who のまま
物では which が only などの付かない名詞の 13% から the only 5%・the same 8%・最上級 9% に減る。the first / last / next は 16% で逆に増える。人では that が 15% → 20〜24% に増えるが、who が多数のまま。
It’s the only explanation that makes sense.
- (2)all / every / any / no が付く 物なら当たる・人は who のまま
物では which が 4〜8%。人では that が 24〜31% で、who が7割を超える。
All the people who attended the meeting were bored.
- (3)everything / anything / nothing が先行詞 当たる
that が 98〜99%。ただし目的格では関係詞を書かない形のほうが多い(everything I know)。
You can take anything you want.
- (4)人と人以外が並ぶ先行詞 まれ
見つかった例は that 4・who 2・which 2。that が多いが who も which も出る。
people and situations that make them relapse
- (5)疑問詞 who が先行詞(Who that …) 今の英語ではほぼ使われない
Who that … は83件、そのうち関係代名詞は6件だけで、19世紀の文章や聖書の文体。残りは Who that?(「あれ誰?」)など。
Who that knows of his misfortunes can help feeling an interest?
- (6)人の性格・状態を表す(the man that he used to be) 当たる(ただし関係詞なしが最多)
関係詞を書くなら that 91%・who 9%。ただし関係詞なしが 83%。
He is not the man he used to be.